Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Lot #548
New York Draft Substitute and Relief Document (1863) - Possible Theodore Allen Fraud Example

New York pays the draft substitute fee of $300 for a man in "Indigent Circumstances," ostensibly a fraud certificate concocted by criminal Theodore Allen

This lot has closed

Estimate: $600+
Sell a Similar Item?
Refer Collections and Get Paid
Share:  

Description

New York pays the draft substitute fee of $300 for a man in "Indigent Circumstances," ostensibly a fraud certificate concocted by criminal Theodore Allen

Civil War-dated partly-printed document, three pages, 8.5 x 7, September 23, 1863. Document issued by the "New York County Substitute and Relief Committee," being a "Certificate in favor of Drafted Member in Indigent Circumstances, showing that he has obtained a Substitute and that he is entitled to have the Money therefore paid by the Comptroller." The certificate affirms Robert McCormack as the draft substitute for Arthur Glynn, who is “in indigent circumstances and has a family wholly depending on him for support.” Signed at the conclusion by Mayor George Opdyke, Comptroller Matthew Brennan, and two supervisors. In fine condition.

The document includes two affixed receipts indicating that McCormack was paid the requisite $300 substitute charge, both of which either mention or are signed by Theodore Allen, ostensibly the noted New York area saloon keeper, criminal, and former butcher's boy for the notorious Bill ‘the Butcher’ Poole. In 1864 he was arrested for participating in a ‘bounty swindling’ fraud scheme, in which men accepted cash bounties for voluntarily enlisting in the Union Army under assumed names before absconding to repeat the process and collect more money. Allen drew a revolver and attempted to shoot the arresting officer, but the gun failed to fire. Allen was later released and was never convicted for the alleged offenses.

Auction Info

  • Auction Title: Fine Autograph and Artifacts Featuring Revolutionary War, The War of 1812, and Civil War
  • Dates: #695 - Ended July 10, 2024